lazarus

A runtime for Minecraft Forge 1.8.9 on modern Java, with optional LWJGL 3 and security patches.

Benchmarks

Method

The smoke mod has a benchmark mode. It creates a world from a fixed seed, waits 15 seconds for chunks to load, turns the frame cap and vsync off, holds the player still and turns the camera one full circle over the run, then prints:

LAZARUS-BENCH fps=… avg_ms=… p50_ms=… p99_ms=… p999_ms=… max_ms=… low1_fps=… frames=… gc=… gc_ms=… heap_mb=…
              java=… gl=… lwjgl=… optifine=…

low1_fps is the average frame rate over the slowest 1% of frames; gc and gc_ms count collections during the run only.

./gradlew :harness:runLazarus25 -PjvmArgs="-Dlazarus.smoke.bench=60"                       # LWJGL 2
./gradlew :harness:runLwjgl3_25 -PjvmArgs="-Dlazarus.smoke.bench=60"                       # LWJGL 3, core renderer
./gradlew :harness:runLwjgl3_25 -PjvmArgs="-Dlazarus.smoke.bench=60 -Dlazarus.gl=compat"   # LWJGL 3, legacy renderer

Add -Poptifine=/path/OptiFine.jar for OptiFine and -PshaderPack=/path/pack.zip for a shader pack. -Dlazarus.smoke.benchDebug=true keeps the F3 screen open. Runs on one machine vary by up to 25%, so compare several runs of each configuration and only compare runs from the same machine.

macOS

MacBook Air M2, macOS 26.5, Java 25.0.5, 30 second runs. On macOS the legacy renderer gets OpenGL 2.1; the core renderer gets OpenGL 4.1.

  Legacy OpenGL 2.1 Core renderer
Vanilla 160 fps 364 fps
OptiFine HD U M5 223 fps 528 fps
OptiFine, F3 open   507 fps

With shader packs, OptiFine HD U M5:

Pack Legacy OpenGL 2.1 Core renderer
BSL 10.1.8 26 fps; shadow program does not compile 81 fps, all programs
Sildur’s Vibrant 2.02 Medium 120 fps; one composite pass does not compile 107 fps, all programs
Complementary Reimagined r5.10 does not load 76 fps, all programs

Apple’s OpenGL 2.1 only accepts GLSL 1.20, which is why packs lose programs on the legacy renderer. The core renderer compiles all of them, so on Sildur’s it does more work than the legacy renderer and the two are not directly comparable.

Windows

Windows 10, NVIDIA RTX 4070, Java 25.0.4, 1280×720, render distance 8.

  Vanilla OptiFine HD U M5
LWJGL 2 491 fps 1475 fps
LWJGL 3 1239 fps 1382 fps
LWJGL 3, core renderer 740 fps 2270 fps

On a driver with a fast legacy OpenGL path, the core renderer is slower on vanilla, where the frame is mostly the game’s own CPU work, and faster with OptiFine. Stock Forge 1.8.9 on Java 8 measures in the same range as Lazarus on Java 25 (666 fps vanilla on LWJGL 2).

Garbage collectors

Java 25, vanilla, two runs per collector, mean frame rate:

Collector Windows, RTX 4070, LWJGL 3 legacy renderer macOS, Apple M2, core renderer
G1 (default) 775 fps 356 fps
Parallel 923 fps 375 fps
ZGC 731 fps 348 fps
Shenandoah 737 fps 349 fps

The differences are within run-to-run noise on the M2, and with OptiFine G1 and Parallel measure the same (525 and 521 fps). ZGC uses two to three times the heap of the others. Lazarus keeps the JVM’s default, G1; -XX:+UseParallelGC is a reasonable alternative on machines where it measures better.